News & Insights

Busting bubble

We've heard a lot in recent years about bursting bubbles in the financial and housing sectors. Now the analogy is creeping into higher education.

In a stark opinion piece published earlier this month in the Washington Examiner, University of Tennessee law professor Glenn Harlan Reynolds declares that the higher education bubble is about to burst. "The product grows more and more elaborate, and more and more expensive," he explains, "but the expense is offset by cheap credit provided by sellers eager to encourage buyers to buy." Remember, he's talking about college degrees, not houses. So if there's an educational bubble, what's inflating it?

The primary cause: skyrocketing costs. Inside Higher Ed reports that private colleges are increasing tuition this fall by an average 4.5 percent, which is extremely modest compared to a 10-year prerecession average of 6 percent per year. (To be fair, student aid is also increasing in these institutions, which isn't always the case in other sectors of higher education.) The problem is that over the last 30 years tuition has far out-paced inflation (as measured by the Consumer Price Index). University of Michigan economist Mark Perry graphs the percentage of increase in housing since 1978 -- a four-fold increase over the CPI -- and then overlays the increase in tuition during the same period -- a ten-fold increase!

"The college tuition bubble makes the housing price bubble seem pretty lame by comparison," says Perry.

At the same time, the Department of Education is getting serious about programmatic assessment. The implied question is this: Are educational institutions delivering on what they promise? Is the product or service really worth the high cost and deep debt?

This new environment is only exacerbated by the new Direct Lending program for student loans. On the one hand, it takes the private lenders providing cheap credit out of the picture. On the other, it means that the U.S. Government has purchased a stake in the quality of higher education and now has a direct interest in the success of students who borrow. It's institutions of higher ed that are now standing between the lender and borrower.

No doubt, this is a game-changer.

So what does all this mean for theological schools? What questions should governing boards and senior administration be asking in this climate? Is there indeed a bubble in theological education, and is it about to burst? 

Read Part 2 of this post.


Image credit

Top Topics

Roles & Responsibilities



Board Essentials

Upcoming Events

The In Trust Center hosts learning community spaces throughout the year. Check out our upcoming events below.

Strategic Partnerhips


In this on-demand webinar, Rick Staisloff, senior partner of rpk GROUP, will discuss essential aspects of strategic partnerships. He will explore current trends, identify partners, navigate the due diligence process, and addresses common challenges. In addition to technical components of partnerships, he will also examine the intangible – yet critical – elements of partnerships, such as building trust and managing relationships.

Closing the Trust Gap


The current and very troubling condition of trust is a clarion call to action. But despite the dismal data showing pervasive organizational distrust, every organization can assess their current level of trust, learn and adopt a proven trust building framework, and then develop a meaningful and long-lasting plan of action. This webinar details the knowledge and practical next steps to strengthen workplace culture as a result of closing the trust gap.

In Trust Center Resource Grants


An In Trust Center Resource Grant offers member schools a chance to explore innovation at their institutions through a matching grant opportunity of up to $15,000. Listen to this 30-minute information session, including Q&A, as we provide details on eligibility requirements, funding priorities, application process. Previous grantees are eligible to apply as long as they are not within our current funding cycle.

Can’t Find What You’re Looking For?

In Trust Center provides Resource Consulting to our members at no charge. Contact us today and let us guide you to the most helpful resources for your situation.

Contact Us