News & Insights

Cross-posted from Rebekah Burch Basinger's blog, Generous Matters. Read her original post here

Topping the list of frequently-asked board-related questions that come my way is how to fill empty board seats with quality recruits. With nonprofits proliferating at breakneck speed, competition for board members is keen. Throw in expectations like competent, committed, and/or generous and you might as well be chasing Bigfoot. There ain’t no such creature out there — or so seems.

Fortunately, there is.

With careful planning and disciplined follow-through, you can build a strong, value-adding board (aka the board your organization needs and deserves). Here’s the five-step path that I suggest when asked for advice on filling a board roster with quality members.


1. Describe your dream-team board. Assembling the board your organization needs and deserves begins by committing to paper a minds-eye portrait of what a dream-team board looks like — physically, spiritually, professionally, demographically, etc. And not just for today, but for five to 10 years down the road. You’re seeking board members who’ll be as likely to advance the organization on their last day of service as their first.

2. Actively seek recruits who fit what you’ve described. Intentionality is the word. Catch as catch can won’t do.

It’s helpful to assign oversight of the identification and search process to a committee, yet essential to keep everyone on the board involved. Make board-building an every-meeting agenda item. And between meetings, do anything and everything possible to find folks who complement the description of your “ideal” board.

3. Have a plan for wooing, vetting, and inviting. Rushing the invitation to board service is as risky and prone to disappointment as proposing marriage on a first date. In board service, as in love, what you see isn’t necessarily what you get. So ask questions, vet, learn to know prospective board members and let them learn to know the organization before you pop the question. The strongest boards maintain an active recruitment pipeline.

4. Honor the newcomer’s commitment with a quality orientation experience. Every recruit, regardless past board experience or how well s/he knows the organization, deserves a thorough orientation to what it means to serve on this particular board, at this particular time, focused on this organization’s particular vision and plans. Whether you’re bringing a few or many to the board, the commitment to orientation should be the same. No board member should take his or her seat without it.

5. Keep a seat or two open. The opposite of rushing board building isn’t holding a ready, able, and ideal candidate at bay until the time is right for the organization. You never know when an absolutely perfect board candidate will cross paths with the organization, so it’s a good idea to keep a seat or two open for the unexpected opportunity.

There you have it, my five-step pathway to a better board. Give it a try. Chances are good you’ll arrive at the board your organization needs and deserves.

For more on building your dream-team board, see:

Cross-posted from Rebekah Burch Basinger's blog, Generous Matters. Read her original post here

Top Topics

Roles & Responsibilities



Board Essentials

Upcoming Events

The In Trust Center hosts learning community spaces throughout the year. Check out our upcoming events below.

I See That Hand


Board members are typically recruited for their leadership, business acumen, and networks. Dr. Rebekah Basinger, project director of the In Trust Center’s Wise Stewards Initiative, will discuss how strategic questioning and interrogation skills are essential for effective board stewardship.

Strategic Partnerships in Higher Education


In this on-demand webinar, Rick Staisloff, senior partner of rpk GROUP, discusses essential aspects of strategic partnerships. This session delves into current trends, identification of partners, navigating the due diligence process, and common challenges.

Closing the Trust Gap


The current and very troubling condition of trust is a clarion call to action. But despite the dismal data showing pervasive organizational distrust, every organization can assess their current level of trust, learn and adopt a proven trust building framework, and then develop a meaningful and long-lasting plan of action. This webinar details the knowledge and practical next steps to strengthen workplace culture as a result of closing the trust gap.

Can’t Find What You’re Looking For?

In Trust Center provides Resource Consulting to our members at no charge. Contact us today and let us guide you to the most helpful resources for your situation.

Contact Us